Well I made it to the hardware store before they closed. Kramer Lumber, though not my favorite, does have a wide variety of selection for the average DIYer. They are also the only glass supplier in town, except for the picture frame shop or the custom stained glass store. A 24x24 piece of glass, cut to fit the frame I took in, only cost me $9.50 plus tax. I guess that's a decent price. At less than a mile round trip, the savings in gas more than make up for any cost savings down in Indy.